Kirkland vs Members Mark Toilet Paper: Quick Comparison

Written by

Paulk Webb


Freddie J. Hagopian

Saveourwaterrebates is reader-supported. When you buy via our links, we may earn a commission at no cost to you. Learn more

kirkland vs members mark toilet paper

Choosing the right toilet paper is not a simple task. Since it’s something that is used daily, every family member in your house should be comfortable with it. In the search of reputable brands, you’ll likely contemplate Kirkland vs Members Mark Toilet Paper.

Kirkland toilet paper has good quality, yet it is inexpensive. If you find out about the price, you’ll surely be attracted to it. Members Mark toilet paper is praised for its dotted texture and two-ply construction. In addition, it has a reasonable amount of torque to prevent ripping. Do you want to learn more about these two toilet paper brands? Read the whole article; it’ll help you come up with the right purchasing decision as well.

Kirkland Toilet Paper


Costco sells a billion rolls of Kirkland toilet paper a year so it’s understandable that the manufacturer is kept as a secret. Your local Costco branch obtains its supply from the nearest provider. The possible manufacturers are Clearwater Paper Corporation, Georgia Pacific, Kimberly Clark, and Proctor and Gamble.

Anyways, regardless of the manufacturer, the more important aspect to consider of any product like this toilet paper is the pros and cons.


  • Uncomplicated to use
  • Cost-efficient
  • Septic-safe
  • Excellent strength when in a dry state
  • Has good softness, thickness, and absorbency
  • Available in all Costco stores


  • May be thinner than other brands

Members Mark Toilet Paper

Who makes Members Mark toilet paper? Many ask this question since Sam’s Club Member’s Mark toilet paper fills the 20% inventory of the said club. Similar to Kirkland, the manufacturer is not disclosed. But Sam’s club stated that they produce the items they sell and collaborate with Walmart. No matter who is responsible, though, most buyers care about the pros and cons:


  • Soft and absorbent
  • Septic safe
  • Strong and sturdy


  • Can be fuzzy

Comparison Table of Kirkland Toilet Paper vs Members Mark Toilet Paper

  Kirkland Members Mark
Price and value $1.25 for a thousand sheets $1.72 for a thousand sheets
Absorbency Medium Medium
Strength in dry state Medium Medium
Strength when wet Medium Medium
Thickness Medium High
Lint-free Medium Low
Dissolvability Low High
Perforation strength Low Medium
Softness Low High

In the Member’s Mark vs Kirkland comparison of qualities, the former has an edge.


Members Mark toilet paper is strong yet soft. With its dotted texture and two-ply structure, it can efficiently absorb moisture even in the messiest situation. Furthermore, its aesthetic is impressive with an abstract floral imprint exuding a luxurious vibe.

Kirkland also offers two-ply toilet paper. Its strength, thickness, and absorbency are all average. But it doesn’t mean that it can’t do its job well. Although the appearance isn’t spectacular, it is a great deal because of its affordable price.

Price and Savings

To figure out the price and cost efficiency, it’s best to look at the amount a single household can spend for each brand. The computation is based on a family of 4: an adult male, adult female, female child, and male child. This family size uses approximately 60,000 sheets per year. Hence, here’s the breakdown:

Kirkland – $75 per year

Members Mark – $103 per year

As you can see, you can save $28 when you choose Kirkland toilet paper.

Access: Where to Purchase

In comparing Members Mark vs Kirkland Toilet Paper, it’s also good to know if the product is accessible. Everyone likes convenience and buying something right away is a relief. You can get Members Mark toilet paper from Sam’s Club or without membership through these options:

  • You can ask a friend or people close to you, who are members of the club, to buy it for you.
  • Sam’s Club welcomes and allows non-members to buy toilet paper in an open house event. You have to grab the chance and buy in bulk.
  • You can buy from an online shopping website. If you’re budget-conscious, you can get an app that helps you compare prices and get the best deal.
  • Sam’s Club offers a free-day pass but you need to pay a 10% charge as a non-member. It’s worth it though because of the value of toilet paper.

Kirkland toilet paper from Costco can be bought online so it’s easy and convenient to process.

Notable Pros and Cons – Comparison Kirkland Toilet Paper and Members Mark Toilet Paper


I have seen notable pros and cons revealed by users on Reddit. So, to save you the trouble of navigating to a different site, I have compiled them here:



  • Pretty strong even when wet
  • Comfortable to use
  • Pleasant appearance
  • Good value and is cost-efficient


  • Plies separate easily
  • Doesn’t have great dissolvability

Members Mark


  • Wonderfully thick
  • Feels like Charmin (What is the difference between Kirkland toilet paper vs Charmin? click here to read now!)
  • Durable


  • Cost more
  • Can be linty (but the company is working on lessening it)


The information shown in this article about Kirkland vs Members Mark toilet paper should help you realize what you have to prioritize. If you’re on a budget, choosing Kirkland won’t bring disappointment because it’s affordable while also serving its purpose. If you can afford the higher price tag, it’s not a bad idea to get Members Mark toilet paper as it can give you a great and luxurious experience.

4/5 - (7 votes)